Won’t you please
observe this photo, taken at the turn of the century. It depicts an unknown early American football team, and I found it at Wikipedia. Look how lean these tiny guys look.
Next, peak at defensive lineman Michael Strahan from the the aptly-named New York Giants. (Link fixed. Thanks, Yoni!)
Yes.
I swear to god, this is a post about brain power, not football, and let me be the first to draw a line from one to the other. Via Boing Boing we learn that Sharpbrains, who manufacture those brain-training software, report that 2007 was a phenomenal year for what they call Brain Fitness software. These programs grossed over 225 million dollars in the US. Real dollars. Not Canadian.
Now, I don’t mind people working hard to get ahead of others. That’s how it’s supposed to be. And as the internet turns knowledge useless and learning abilities crucial, we all expected that sooner or later people will want to do whatever they can to sharpen their minds. It’s the euphemisms I can’t stand. Brain Fitness. Brain Fitness. Fitness is what you do when you want to get leaner or prevent heart disease: you don’t get on the NFL for being lean. No. You get puffed up. You get engineered from early age to be huge. Huge! We’re saying brain fitness here, but what we mean is Giant Heads.
Not everybody wants to play defense for the New York Giants, but everybody wants a big mind. Pretty soon it’ll be a race we will all have to run in. Giant craniums all around. Let me say this: I wouldn’t be opposed to having my brain be a little leaner. Those slopes of abstract thought are getting steeper, and I for one wouldn’t mind scaling them with a little less huffing and puffing. But soon enough, I swear to god, all around you, in the street, on the line to the bank, sitting next to you when you’re waiting for a job interview, all these guys with bulbous craniums. People with portly heads testifying, just as muscular men do today, that they took no brain enhancing drugs. Giant heads, perhaps with USB 3.0 ports right behind the left ear. And I, for one, I don’t think that’s fair. I want to retain the right to be lazy and unexercised and still be considered smart. After all, that’s what being a geek is all about.
אני לא בטוחה שאני מבינה. כן, מטאפורה מגניבה כל עניין המוח המנופח מסטריאודים. אבל יש בזה משהו מעבר למטאפורה המגניבה? מה המקבילה בעולם האמיתי של סטירואידי-מוח?
Comment by achmo 03.12.08 @ 5:39 amIn brains, as far as I see it, there’s volume and there’s usage. There’s how much you can store, how much you can process — that’s usually a given — and what you do with it, which is subject to how we teach ourselves to use what we have. I, for instance, am very bad at using the formidable mass of brain I was given, often failing to remember what I was talking about by the time I reach the middle of a.
What’s scary now is that other, maybe less endowed, will gain over us gifted sloths by increasing their brain mass while actually taking pains to use them. Brrrr.
Comment by Jonathan Silber 03.12.08 @ 5:46 amאתה יוצא מתוך ההנחה שיש איזה סף מסה, שאם עוברים אותו אז הכמות מפצה על היעדר האיכות. אני לא חושבת שזה נכון. שפע של מידע עדיין לא מבטיח יכולת לעשות איתו משהו.
Comment by achmo 03.12.08 @ 6:00 amWe’re not talking about the ability to store information. There’s good evidence to show that this capacity is virtually unlimited. The bigger brain capacity is to access and utilize this info: being able to remember more, to calculate better, to find new links between stored pieces of data.
Comment by Jonathan Silber 03.12.08 @ 6:09 amYou realize right now Canadian dollars are worth MORE (by about 2 cents) than those crappy American dollars, right?
Hmpf.
Comment by Dubi 03.12.08 @ 8:59 pmI refuse to accept that.
Comment by Jonathan Silber 03.12.08 @ 9:08 pm